Here are six recommendations for improving transparency while maintaining flexibility:

Detail every contract: Even for smaller contracts, ensure detailed titles, deliverables and justifications for vendor selection. Avoid open-ended coaching or consulting contracts without clear outcomes. Superintendents should publicly post all contract awards, providing clear explanations for why a vendor was selected.
Consolidate vendors: Instead of using many different vendors for smaller contracts, reduce the appearance of favoritism by consolidating services with a few trusted, competitively chosen vendors. Consider using “comprehensive service agreements”—master agreements that consolidate several subcontractors under one contract.
Solicit multiple quotes: Even for contracts under formal bidding thresholds, solicit quotes from at least three vendors to ensure fair pricing and avoid the perception of no-bid favoritism.
Involve the board early: Superintendents should inform their boards about discretionary contracts, particularly those that might raise public concerns. While board action may not be required, written documentation of the decision-making process should be shared regularly.
Provide regular updates on discretionary spending: Implement a system for tracking and reviewing how funds are allocated and updating the board regularly on smaller contracts and discretionary spending. Embed vendor accountability into the bid itself by requiring vendors to include specific key performance indicators (KPIs) that reduce the data burden on the system.
Track and report 'learning on investment': In a previous article we introduced the concept of “learning on investment,” the amount of student learning gain per dollar invested. Calculating “LOI” before reinvesting demonstrates fiscal responsibility.

Improving board accountability

Surprisingly, some school boards show limited interest in fiscal oversight, despite it being one of their most critical governance roles. As Morales observes, "Some districts don't even want to hear about finance. When they do, they focus on individual transactions, not the big picture." This reactive approach often leaves superintendents vulnerable when financial problems inevitably arise.

Instant Insights /

Financial challenges: How to guide districts with transparency

Related Stories

Recommended For You